posted 27th July 2025
For small businesses in Birmingham, Wolverhampton, Coventry, and across the West Midlands, the small claims court is often the go-to solution for recovering unpaid invoices, resolving contract breaches, or handling property damage claims.
While the process is designed to be accessible, many business owners make costly mistakes that harm their chances of success.
At Meridian Legal Services, we help West Midlands companies avoid these pitfalls and secure the outcomes they deserve.
Mistake 1: Failing to Send a Proper Letter Before Action (LBA).
A Letter Before Action is not optional—it’s a legal requirement. This formal letter allows the other party to resolve the matter before court proceedings begin.
Many business owners either fail to send one or send an inadequate letter lacking details like deadlines or the legal basis for the claim.
Without this, you risk the court reducing your cost recovery or dismissing your case.
In Birmingham and surrounding areas, we frequently draft LBAs that prompt immediate settlements without ever stepping into court.
Mistake 2: Suing the Wrong Defendant.
Targeting the correct defendant is crucial. For sole traders, you need their personal name, while for limited companies, the official name and registered office address are essential.
Using the wrong details can delay your case or lead to dismissal. West Midlands companies often trade under different names—checking Companies House ensures you sue the right entity.
Mistake 3: Missing Key Deadlines.
The small claims track has strict procedural rules. From filing claims to submitting evidence, missing deadlines can result in a case being struck out.
Many SMEs juggle daily operations and underestimate the importance of court timelines.
Having a clear plan, and ideally, professional support from Meridian Legal Services, will ensure you don't make helps this costly error.
Meridian Legal Services offers local expertise to keep you compliant at every step.
Mistake 4: Lack of Sufficient Evidence
Evidence wins cases. Relying solely on verbal agreements or unsigned contracts is risky. Always preserve invoices, receipts, delivery notes, email communications, and photos if relevant.
Courts rely on clear, documented proof. In the West Midlands, many strong claims fail simply due to inadequate record-keeping.
We advise clients on gathering and presenting robust evidence packs that increase their chances of success.
Mistake 5: Overclaiming or Adding Unjustified Costs.
Overstating losses or adding speculative costs undermines credibility. For example, adding arbitrary interest rates or “administrative fees” not in the original agreement can reduce awards or cost penalties. Always keep claims realistic and backed by documentation.
This is where our legal review can be invaluable—ensuring your claim is reasonable, evidence-backed, and well-presented.
Mistake 6: Delaying Professional Advice.
Many businesses only seek help when a hearing date has already been set, limiting options for resolution. Getting advice early can prevent procedural errors, help structure your case, and lead to faster settlements.
Whether you need help writing an LBA or representing yourself in court, our West Midlands team is here to support you.
Don't Risk Small Claims Mistakes - Contact Meridian Legal Services.
Avoiding these common mistakes can significantly improve your chances of success in small claims court. Preparation is key, from properly drafting pre-action letters to ensuring evidence and timelines are in order.
Ready to take your small claims case seriously? Contact Meridian Legal Services today for expert advice tailored to West Midlands businesses.
We offer free initial consultations to help you start on the right foot. Whether you have a small claim or a fast-track claim, we can help. Contact us today to evaluate your case.
Need a Barrister? Click here.
